Genesis Ranked
Here are the definitive rankings of all the Genesis studio albums. I showed this list to all the members of the band, and they said it was accurate. In particular, when Tony Banks saw it, he actually smiled, and that man never smiles.
- Calling All Stations
- This is the one and only post-Collins Genesis album, and it sounds like a Mike + The Mechanics album left in the work fridge over the Christmas holidays.
- From Genesis to Revelation
- The first album is totally unrecognizable as the prog band Genesis would become. The album cover was so generic a lot of records stores thought it belonged in the religious section.
- We Can't Dance
- When I first got into Genesis, it was during Invisible Touch, the predecessor to this album. This could have been a post-No Jacket Required Phil Collins album (that's bad).
- Trespass
- This is Genesis almost finding its sound. There are some tracks here that feel like they could have been in Ralph Bakshi's LOTR movie (derogatory) but The Knife goes hard.
- Abacab
- This could have been the undisputed best album in the history of the universe (it's not) but if you put Who Dunnit? on it, it has to drop near the bottom. Even if you don't listen to it, just read the lyrics. It's such a bad song; it's the cringiest thing they ever did (not the worst, that's on...)
- Genesis
- And it's called Illegal Alien. If you want to see Phil Collins in brownface, here you go. I love the "oh yeah, we used to be a prog band" double track Home By The Sea, of which I once did an impromptu interpretive pantomime for Tara in a Pasadena burger joint. This album also features the song I always hear while shopping at H-E-B.
- Invisible Touch
- This was my entry for Genesis and my first concert at 14 at Exhibition Place in Toronto (a.k.a. The Mistake By The Lake). It's by far their biggest-selling album, coasting off the success of No Jacket Required by Phil Collins the year before. Over half the album feels like a sequel to that, which would be fine if it was a Phil Collins solo album, but it's not. All that said, The Brazilian at the end of the album is one of my favourite instrumentals from the pop era.
- Wind & Wuthering
- It's an oddly subdued album considering it follows A Trick Of The Tail. Its sound is consistent bordering on repetitive, but shout-out to All In A Mouse's Night, an insane multiple-POV song about newlyweds spotting a mouse in their house, catching it, it escaping, bumping into the cat, and just as the cat is going to kill, a giant 10-foot mouse appears and kills the cat.
- ...And Then There Were Three
- The first album after Hackett left arguably changed the sound of Genesis more than Peter Gabriel's departure. It's where you start to see the band farting around with pop a bit with stuff like Follow You, Follow Me. Fav track is Many Too Many.
- Nursery Cryme
- This is the third Genesis album and the first that's full-on prog and that 'Genesis sound'. There are some really fucked-up tracks like The Musical Box and just weird stuff like Harold The Barrel, the song about (and sung by) the various parties gathering around a potential jumper.
- The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway
- Ooooh, you're mad this is only placed in fifth, aren't you? This double album that often tops the list of not only Genesis albums but prog albums? Fifth? Well, when it hits, it hits (first disc) but it also shows the messy and rushed production (second disc). Also, come on, the story is pretty puerile. That said, The Carpet Crawlers is a masterpiece, and probably my favorite Genesis song. Oh, also, the Greek-like Genesis word-mark here is the one I always associate with them.
- Foxtrot
- This is super-condensed Genesis prog. The songs are about: an alien checking out Earth after we all killed ourselves; playing with genetics to shrink people so apartment buildings can be more profitable; a 23-minute-long epic about the Apocalypse.
- Duke
- Selling England by the Pound
- The most crisp of the Gabriel-era Genesis albums features Tony Banks's classic intro on Firth Of Fifth, a Gen Z anthem about a lawnmower who just wants to make enough money to enjoy his time off, and a riff on 70s austerity Britain meets medieval metaphors!
- A Trick Of The Tail
- The first Collins-era Genesis album is my gold standard. Story-driven songs that go hard like the opening track, a couple of great sweeping ballads, another multiple POV song about a break-in, and the all-timer instrumental Los Endos.